Sunday, August 21, 2005

Daylight Savings time "boondoggle"

I think the political ramifications of Indiana switching to Daylight Savings time are going to be very interesting. I also feel that Daylight Savings time will effect the 2006 elections and possibly the 2007 elections in Indiana.

I am particularly interested in how parts of the State are effected whose State legislators decided to vote against their constituents.

A great example of this is State Representative Phyllis Pond and State District 85, which she represents. About 70% of the people in this district did NOT want to switch to Daylight Savings time.

Phyllis Pond voted in favor of switching to Daylight Savings time. In other words, she voted directly against the wishes of her constituents.

11 comments:

Bartleby said...

Why do you say that 70% of the residents of District 85 oppose DST?

LP Mike Sylvester said...

She puts out a legislative survey. In that survey 70% of respondents were against DST.

Bartleby said...

So, what we actually know is that 70% of a self-selected sample (those who responded) of her constituents oppose DST.

This may seem like quibbling (and indeed, it may BE quibbling), but I think it goes to one's basic understanding of the role of a legislative representative in a republic. Many people think a representative is supposed to find out, somehow, what the majority of the represented think, and vote that way. In that understanding, the proverbial moistened finger held up in the breeze is actually a virtuous thing. The representative is just a poll-taker. Quite apart from the problem of scientifically finding out the majority's wishes, the "representative," in that model, could well be automated. Your state rep doesn't have to be a person, he/she could be a java script.

I think the representative ought to make his or her principles clear when seeking office, and thereafter, act on those principles. The function of a representative, in my model, is to be the person whose duty it is to be fully informed about public questions, and then to act as I would act if I were fully informed about all questions. This frees me, as the useful citizen, to pursue my calling without having to lobby my representative ceaselessly, for fear that those of opposing opinions are doing so, and that my weathervane representative will simply turn according to the prevailing wind.

BTW, as far as I'm concerned, DST sucks.

Lewis said...

I agree with Bartleby in as much as once we elect our representatives they should inform themselves and vote not by polls, but by making the best and most informed decision possible for the public good.
I also think that our governor has spent so much time on this issue that he is wasting our tax dollars. After all we pay his salary.
The sun is going to come up every morning based on its relationship to the earth. It doesn't really matter to me what time you call it when the arrangement of the sun and the Earth come into proper alignment for their to be sunshine in my area.
A rose by any other name would smell as sweet to me, and I don't care if you call it midnight when the sun comes up in Indiana. If the sun is up I'll still say that it's daytime.

LP Mike Sylvester said...

I agree that legislative surveys are just a tool and that politicians should NOT always heed them.

However, when legislating something like time; I would think a diligent politican would vote the way 70% of the respondents want them to rather then vote with a Political Party.

Mike Kole said...

If legislators should just be elected and then lead, then why on earth even bother with a poll? Seems like wasted money, if that's your perspective.

No, maybe the Rep wanted to give constitutents the illusion of participation or being heard, while she goes right ahead and does whatever she wants, knowing full well that her district is gerrymandered, and that the likelihood of a serious challenge is nil.

Clickbank Mall said...

Simple Tasks Create Lots of Cash
surveys uk
Are you interested?
surveys uk
Then Try This!
surveys uk

job opportunitya said...

Captivating blog. I love surfing the web for the
type of blogs that you do. It had me on the edge of my
seat and I kept going back to again and again!
I want you to stop and compare with my atlanta equity home loan rate blog.

Anonymous said...

You have an outstanding good and well structured site. I enjoyed browsing through it
»

Anonymous said...

That's a great story. Waiting for more. pilates + history Bingo easier faster wyndham sappire hotel st lucia west indies

Anonymous said...

What a great site film editing schools